Related Articles
Start Backtesting

Extrinsic vs Intrinsic Value Options: 3 Key Differences

March 18, 2022
Albert Huang
Tradewell logo

Options contracts are some of the most powerful financial instruments available to traders. However, options are also complex. Therefore anyone who trades options seriously should be able to answer one of the most fundamental options questions: from where do options get their value?

How are Options Priced?

The price of an option, also referred to as the “option premium”, is the price the buyer pays to the contract “writer”. Options traders typically rely on a formula called “Black-Scholes” or “Black-Scholes-Merton” to calculate their value. This formula was created in 1973 by three Nobel prize-winning economists.

To this day, the equation remains the most widely accepted formula in options pricing because it easily allows traders to input discoverable data points of an underlying security and its option contract as a means of arriving at a fair value.

It should be mentioned that although the Black-Scholes-Merton equation is quite useful, it fails to account for some variables that have a material effect on the option’s price, such as dividend payouts issued by the underlying security over the life of the options contract.

The equation does, however, take into account most of the key drivers of an option’s value. The equation to price a call option contract per the Black-Scholes-Merton method appears below.

While this equation may seem complicated, you don’t need to feel intimidated. It’s more  important to understand the overall theory of two of the key components expressed here – extrinsic and intrinsic value – than it is to understand the math behind the formula.

What is the Extrinsic Value of an Option?

The extrinsic value of an option is what traders sometimes call its “time value”. This is the component of the option that represents the value of all the possible paths that the underlying security could take between now and the expiration date. The extrinsic value is calculated by subtracting the intrinsic value, which will be discussed in the following section, from the total option price.

Another way to think about the extrinsic value of the option is that it represents the value of uncertainty. 

Uncertainty offers value to both the buyer and seller of an option because it represents the potential for an option to settle in or out of the money. The greater the uncertainty, the higher the potential for either scenario to transpire.

To account for this uncertainty, the Black-Scholes-Merton formula fits a probability distribution around two key parameters of the underlying security. We will discuss this calculation  in greater detail later.

What is the Intrinsic Value of an Option?

The intrinsic value of the option, also known as the “parity value”, is the difference between the current price of the underlying security and the strike price of the option contract. The wrinkle, however, is that the minimum intrinsic value can never fall below zero.

It’s far easier to calculate the intrinsic value of a call option., Simply take the current price of the underlying security and subtract  the strike price of the option. To calculate the intrinsic value of a put option, take the strike price and subtract the underlying security’s current price. Intrinsic value is therefore a function of a single parameter:the difference between the underlying security’s current price and the option’s strike price.

3 Differences Between the Extrinsic and Intrinsic Value of Options

Now that we have covered the topics of extrinsic value and intrinsic value,, let’s dive a bit deeper into three key differences between them.

Underlying Price Component

The intrinsic value of an option is a function of the underlying security’s current price relative to the option’s strike price. Extrinsic value on the other hand is derived independently of those two variables. Instead, extrinsic value  is dependent on the implied volatility of the underlying security and the time-to-expiration of the option contract. 

Volatility Component

Implied volatility is the rate at which the market believes the price of a security will increase or decrease over a particular period of time in the future. It is often calculated with standard deviation as an input, and may at times be expressed through measurements such as “variance” and “beta”.

The Black-Scholes-Merton equation uses Standard deviation in its a proxy for the uncertainty surrounding where the price of the underlying will settle at the time of expiration.

Recall that extrinsic value refers to the component of the option pricing formula that represents the value of that uncertainty, or in other words, the path of price action that a security might experience between now and expiration. Also recall that intrinsic value functions independently of the implied volatility of the underlying security. The greater the implied volatility of a security, the greater the number of “paths” its price may take towards it settlement on expiration.

Moreover, a trader should be willing to pay more for an option contract whose underlying exhibits greater implied volatility because the price movement indicates that there is a greater chance that the security will settle above the strike price for a call or below the strike price for a put, at the time of expiration. The implied volatility component is comparable to the time component, which we will describe below, in terms of its influence on elements of the extrinsic value of an options contract..

Time Component

The time component is the part of an option’s extrinsic value that represents the decaying value between the current day and the expiration date. It’s typically calculated using trading days as units. The impact of the time component functions the same across options types, meaning there is no difference in influence depending on whether the instrument is a call or put. All things being equal, the value of an option   naturally decreases as the number of days-to-expiration gets smaller. Intuitively, this positive relationship between time-to-expiration and the value of the options contract makes sense. It relies on the same logic that we used when determining the value of the volatility component earlier:. The greater the number of days to expiration, the greater the number of paths that the price of the underlying security can take between now and the day of expiration. Together with the volatility component, the time component of an option contract make up the total extrinsic value of an option. Intrinsic value on the other hand, had no relationship to the amount of time that remains on an options contract before it expires.

Example Scenario

To better illustrate how the concepts of intrinsic and extrinsic value relate to the aggregate price of an options contract, we use a few a real-world examples of options on Tesla and Apple stock.

TSLA and AAPL Call Options

Tesla Inc (TSLA) is a security that currently exhibits an implied volatility of 34% for the 3/18/2022 option expiry.. Implied volatility is simply a measure of the expected annualized volatility of the underlying security that options traders are pricing into the option and is calculated by solving the Black-Scholes-Merton equation for the volatility term. AAPL’s implied volatility for the 3/18/2022 expiry is 24% which would indicate that options traders are expecting AAPL to exhibit lower volatility than TSLA over the period ended on the expiration date. Later on, we’ll see how this stark difference in implied volatility is what is called the “volatility component” of options, resulting in a material difference in the price of options for these two companies.

Let’s take a look at the option chain for Tesla. The chain lists each option with a 3/18/2022 expiration date, ordered by ascending strike prices. The strike price values range from $750 to $785. At the time this article was written, Tesla stock was trading at $766.37 per share. For the purpose of this exercise, let’s focus on the numbers in the columns outlined in red–the strike price (left) and option price (right).

First, let’s calculate the intrinsic value of the call option with the $750 strike price (see line 1). Remember, the underlying stock currently trades at a price of $766.37. We can calculate the intrinsic value for this option by taking the current price of the underlying and subtracting the strike price. This results in an intrinsic value of $16.37. 

We also notice that this contract commands a market price of $35.10, meaning that the contract trades at a premium of $18.73 to its intrinsic value.  The market is pricing in this extrinsic value due to uncertainty surrounding the future price of the underlying. They believe that the price of the underlying shares could move enough between the current date and expiration to justify the price of the option beyond its intrinsic value. 

We can isolate the volatility component of extrinsic value by comparing two contracts with a similar amount of intrinsic value. In our example, we’ll compare an AAPL call to taTSLA call. Recall that in our previous example, TSLA exhibited a beta whose value amounted to almost twice the value of AAPL’s. We can therefore intuit that an AAPL call option whose intrinsic value and expiry are identical to equivalent properties of a TSLA call option would trade at a lower price. 

In line three of the option chain above, we see a quote for an AAPL call option whose strike price and expiration match the price and expiration of the TSLA call in our previous example. Given that AAPL shares currently trade at $150.62, we know that the intrinsic value of the option equals $16.62. The extrinsic value, or the remaining value of the option after subtracting the intrinsic value from the option’s quoted price of $22.60, equals $5.98. This figure amounts to far less than the $18.73 in extrinsic value that a  TSLA contract of similar intrinsic value commands. The difference in extrinsic values can be explained by the fact that traders assign greater expectations of future volatility for TSLA stock relative to AAPL stock.

Finally, to illustrate the time component of an options contract, let’s look at the example of the TSLA contract depicted in the image below. This example is similar in nearly every way to the previous one, except that the contract is set to expire one week later on 3/25/2022. 

While this new option also offers the right  to buy TSLA at the identical strike price of $750, it expires a full week later,,which results in its price being $13.76 greater than the 3/18/2022 contract. We can attribute all of this difference to the time value component of extrinsic value because by comparing two contracts that share the same underlying security, we can be sure that the volatility and intrinsic value are identical.

Final Thoughts

Options are a sophisticated asset class that offer traders unique opportunities to express bets on both the direction of a security and its future volatility. Traders who want to incorporate options strategies into their approach will benefit from understanding how they are priced. The value of an options contract can be broken down into two key components: extrinsic value and intrinsic value. The ability of a trader to understand the drivers behind both of these components is critical to a trader’s success in options trading.

Read This Next
Albert Huang
Deep Out of the Money Options Strategy Explained‍
A deep out of the money option contract is a financial instrument traders use to wager that the price of a security will be far different from the current price at some point in the future.
Read Article
Humza Sarwar
VWMA vs VWAP: Calculation, Trading, and Settings
Understanding how VWAP and VWMA are calculated, how to interpret their output, and when to use them can potentially help traders become better at their craft. 
Read Article
Albert Huang
Extrinsic vs Intrinsic Value Options: 3 Key Differences
Anyone who trades options seriously should be able to answer one of the most fundamental options questions: from where do options get their value?
Read Article
Albert Huang
5 Predictive Stock Market Indicators
The indicators that traders use to determine the future prospects of individual securities and of the market at large are wide ranging. However, not all indicators are created equal.
Read Article
Humza Sarwar
3 Effective Options Strategies For a Sideways Market
Traders often find it difficult to profit from stock in “sideways markets” as the stock trades within a narrow range of support and resistance.
Read Article
Humza Sarwar
Is Averaging Down a Good Idea?
Averaging down is a simple strategy investors use for this purpose. When investors average down, they add shares of an existing position at a lower cost basis.
Read Article
Humza Sarwar
What is an h-pattern in trading and how to trade it?
An h-pattern is a chart pattern that emerges when a security that has fallen precipitously later retests the low point of its recent decline, making fresh lows.
Read Article
Albert Huang
What is the Break-Even Price of an Option? 
In options trading, the term “break-even price” describes the price that the underlying shares of an options contract must reach by the option’s expiration in order for the owner of the option to avoid losing money on its purchase.
Read Article
Albert Huang
How to Find a Trading Edge
In this article, we'll discuss the concept of edge and teach you how to use the Tradewell platform to identify whether or not your trading strategy provides one.
Read Article
Albert Huang
5 Best Implied Volatility Indicators
While there are many implied volatility indicators, not all are created equal. In this article, we will explore five of the most important implied volatility indicators.
Read Article
Humza Sarwar
Put vs Short: Know the Difference
Although buying put options and short selling may seem similar, there are key differences when it comes to their suitability for different trading strategies, and their risk and return profiles.
Read Article
Get started with Tradewell for free

Start with the free version and upgrade when you need a larger metric library and longer lookback periods.

TradeBlock logo
FRED logo
CBOE logo
IEX logo
EIA logo
CME Group logo
Tradewell logo
© 2021 Tradewell, Inc. All rights reserved.
Start Backtesting